While fretting over the impending loss of their computer expert, Gene Toy, and Karp’s request that Pindar erase an embarrassing video from the law firm’s server, Peter and Jared agree to represent Jennifer Putnam in her lawsuit against “Stirred” magazine. Though their client is as yet sight unseen, Jared is certain they can win the case in which Jennifer says she was fired for being too attractive. However, he and Peter have been tricked into betting with Karp on the outcome of the case, and they soon discover that their new client is actually quite plain. But rather than admitting defeat, Jared redoubles his efforts to win Jennifer’s case against publisher Katherine Mack, the daughter of the magazine’s legendary playboy founder, Big Mack. Meanwhile, when Gene Toy claims that he has been wrongfully accused of theft and this has made him persona non grata in Chinatown, Peter tries unsuccessfully to get the store’s owner, Mr. Han, to back down. Upon realizing that Jennifer has no intention of dropping the lawsuit and that she sees herself as being very beautiful, Peter refuses Katherine’s settlement offer. And while Hanna recommends dropping the case, Jennifer manages to pull the lawyers back in. So, as the guys set out to argue for Jennifer’s unparalleled beauty, Hanna joins them in the courtroom. Meanwhile, with Gene Toy ready to give up and leave Los Angeles in order to avoid further humiliation, Infeld agrees to argue his case before the all-powerful Chinatown Council. Though a courtroom stunt nearly gets Peter charged with contempt, he continues to refuse Katherine Mack’s offers to settle. While the guys are attending a “Stirred” charity fundraiser they notice Big Mack devoting a lot attention to Jennifer. They then realize that firing Jennifer was solely Katherine’s idea. After pressing Katherine about her relationship with her father, it’s clear that Katherine fired Jennifer because Jennifer was the daughter Big Mack had always wanted. Finally, as Big Mac
